Will Kentucky Derby Betting Winnings be Redistributed after Medina Spirit’s Failed Test?

Kentucky Derby and Medina Spirit Failed Test

On Sunday, May 5th, competitive horseracing was thrown into turmoil by the news that Medina Spirit, winner of the 147th Kentucky Derby, might face disqualification. The thoroughbred tested positive for elevated levels of betamethasone, an anti-inflammatory that is banned for competing horses.

Trainer Bob Baffert was subsequently suspended from Louisville’s Churchill Downs, and if a second test comes back with the same finding, Medina Spirit’s win will be invalid.
Second place finisher Mandaloun will become the winner.
[su_panel color=”#00000″ border=”4px solid #00329A”]What does this mean for bettors? Can Medina Spirit winnings be clawed back? Can Mandaloun ticketholders receive a payout?[/su_panel]

The Letter of the Law

The Kentucky Horse Racing Commission regulation is clear. Section 10 states that payouts are made “on the basis of the order of finish as declared ‘official’ by the stewards or judges.” The regulation goes on to say that no decision made after the official declaration affects the payouts.

Nevada casinos, which took bets separately from Kentucky, abide by the same standard. They payout according to the official judgment on Derby Day, regardless of any subsequent changes.

Historical Precedents

[su_panel color=”#00000″ border=”4px solid #00329A”]This would hardly be the first time that the first horse over the finish line didn’t end up winning the Kentucky Derby.[/su_panel]

Only two years ago, Maximum Security finished first in the field, but his win was invalidated for interference with another horse. However, the race results were not finalized at the time of the disqualification. Consequently, the official decision correctly reflected second-finishing horse Country House as the winner.

In 1968, first-finisher Dancer’s Image tested positive phenylbutazone after the official declaration. He was disqualified, and runner-up Forward Pass became the winner. Dancer’s Image bettors still got the payout, since he was first on the official raceday decision. The 1968 running is a good antecedent for what will happen if Medina Spirit gets nixed.

The Bottom Line

If you already cashed your Medina Spirit ticket, you can go ahead and spend that money. Indeed, even if you haven’t redeemed that ticket, it will continue to stand even if the horse’s win is invalidated.

On the other hand, those of you with Mandaloun tickets are likely out of luck.

Without a doubt, a Medina Spirit disqualification would be an ugly moment for horseracing. Even so, it has been educational for those that bet on the sport.

Top Horse Racing betting Sites

Nitrobetting Review Nitrobetting Review
5 / 5
Read review

100% Welcome Deposit Bonus Up To m₿25

Get DealGet Deal
18+T&C's apply
18+ only. Full terms and conditions apply.
Betwhale ag Betwhale ag
5 / 5
Read review

125% Welcome Deposit Bonus Up To $1,250

Get DealGet Deal
18+T&C's apply
18+ only. 125% deposit bonus for sports. Bonus terms: minimal deposit - $50, Wagering x10(deposit+bonus), no max CO, minimal odd until wagering is met is -200 (1.5 decimal), valid only for the 1st deposit
Wintoro.ag Review Wintoro.ag Review
5 / 5
Read review

125% Welcome Deposit Bonus Up To $625

Placing wagers at Wintoro.ag comes with its own thrilling perks. As a new member, you'll be greeted with a generous welcome bonus to kick-start your winning streak. These guys obvioulsy believe in rewarding their loyal players, which is why they offer ongoing promotions and exclusive rewards. Prepare to take advantage of incredible offers that will enhance your gameplay and make every bet count.

Get DealGet Deal
18+T&C's apply
18+. Wintoro reserves the right to change or alter the Terms and Conditions of any promotion at any time without notice.
All free plays bonuses expire in 45 days or less unless otherwise stated. Any unused free plays will disappear from your account.
Free Play Bonuses are for straight wagers only. Players can not use them on Casino, Racebook, or Live Betting.
Rollovers must be completed before requesting a payout.
Some players may not qualify for a Wintoro bonus.
Casino Action, Live Wagering, eSports, Horse Action, Asian Handicapping, Soccer Under bets, Propositions, Matchups, Futures, and Push or Cancelled wagers DO NOT count towards the Welcome, 25% Cash, Refer a Friend, or Reload Bonus rollovers. No sports wagers count towards the casino bonus or horse rebate rollovers.
Bookmaker.eu Bookmaker.eu
5 / 5
Read review

100% freeplay bonus Up To $500 on Deposits (Use Promo Code: NFL500)

The Bookmaker.eu has been around since 1996 and knows a thing or two about offering great lines after all it's “Where The Line Originates”. with 24/7 Customer support, fast payouts, and a tasty 100% deposit bonus worth up to $500 with promo code: NFL500

Get DealGet Deal
18+T&C's apply
18+. Full terms and conditions apply. Get a 25% cash bonus, up to $500, on your first deposit using any method besides cryptocurrency. 10x rollover requirement on deposit amount + bonus before any withdrawals can be made.
Jazz Sports Review Jazz Sports Review
5 / 5
Read review

75% Up to $2,500 Sports Welcome Bonus on 1st Deposit

Collect a Jazz Sportsbook 100% Welcome Bonus (75% Sports and 25% Casino) when you join today and make your first deposit. Use the Promo Code: JAZZ100 to qualify on your deposit.

Get DealGet Deal
18+T&C's apply
18+ Full terms and conditions apply.
Andy nelson owner of offshoresportsbookfact.net

Andy Nelson

Andy has been writing and posting about offshore sportsbooks for over 15 years. He's also an active sportsbook bonus seeker and seasoned online gambler on US sports.


Relevant news

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x